Audiobook Sunday‘ is a brand new feature by BCC reviewer, Laura, who will be listening to and then review an audiobook. This feature will be posted monthly.

This month’s Audiobook Sunday is ‘Dangerous‘ by Diane Palmer



Title: Dangerous
Author: Diana Palmer
Publisher: Brilliance Audio
Audiobook Publication Date: May 2010
Audiobook: 9 hours & 8 mins
Narrator: Phil Gigante
Genre: Contemporary Romance
Source: Own Copy

REVIEW BY LAURA

RATING: 1/10 – One of the worst books I have ever read


SUMMARY


Tall, lean and headstrong, FBI agent Kilraven lives by his own rules. And one of those rules includes keeping his hands off Jacobsville’s resident sweetheart, Winnie Sinclair, no matter the temptation. Shy and innocent, Winnie couldn’t handle a man like him — a merciless man with a haunted past. And this small town may hold not only the woman he fights to resist, but the answers to a cold case that is very personal to Kilraven….


Winnie has had her own share of sorrow and senses Kilraven’s pain. Even though she tries to deny it, the gentle 911 operator feels a connection with the darkly handsome agent. When he makes the disturbing discovery that her family’s unsavory past might have a bearing on his case, Winnie is determined to help him crack it…and the ice around his heart.

As they combine forces in a dangerous investigation, the stakes rise ever higher. Winnie’s life is on the line, and she’ll need Kilraven more than ever. But if they are to have a future together, her ruthless Texan will need to confront his past and risk it all for their love. (Goodreads)

REVIEW


*Warning this review contains spoilers*

I’m not usually one for sweeping statements, but I’m afraid I’m going to have to go with it here. This has to be on the list as one of the worst contemporary romances I’ve read. I will put a caveat and say that some people on Goodreads have given it 4 or 5 stars so this is my personal opinion, but it was sheer grit and determination that I persevered until the end. I’ve read a few Diana Palmer books before and I’ve found them a fun and cosy.

This is the story of FBI agent Kilraven and sweet and quiet dispatcher Winnie. Winnie has had a soft spot for Kilraven for a long time, but having lost his wife and daughter in a shoot out relating to a crime he was investigating, Kilraven does not want to settle down again.

My biggest problem with this novel is that the plot was both confusing and had a lot of holes in it. The murder mystery element of the story gets incredibly confusing. There are lots of characters and sub plots running which makes it very hard to keep track. I ended up getting a little lost as to who was who, and who was a suspect.

Then there were the general plot holes. For example, I found it quite remarkable after in the early chapters Winnie comments on how much she and her estranged mother look alike, so much so that her father used to beat her for it. Then when it turns out that Kilraven has been friends and worked with her mother in the FBI for years, he is stunned to find out she is Winnie’s mother. Additionally, Kilraven’s brother, also in the FBI, is in charge of the investigation into her wife and daughter’s murder. What about personal interest? And there are lots of incidents like this, that just do not add up.

While this book was a contemporary romance, the story would have been much better suited as a historical. Firstly, let’s take the reason Kilraven and Winnie ‘have’ to get married. During the course of the investigation, they will be staying alone in Winnie’s family home in the Carribbean. As Winnie is a virgin, Kilraven does not want to sully her reputation by staying with her. So his solution to this problem is to marry her. Of course he then adds that they can then have have a dirty weekend together and then he can just divorce her afterwards! Despite knowing that Winnie has the total hots for him too. Despite my moral objection to Kilraven’s view of using and discarding Winnie. Do people really think about women’s reputations like this anymore?

Then, while discussing his problems with ex-wife, Kilraven’s expresses how upset he was that his wife wasn’t a virgin on their wedding night. I can take the fact that in a romance that more often that not the heroine is a virgin is this is part of the formula, and actually I usually find it quite sweet. But, let’s face it this is the 21st century and the author needs to treat her readers like modern women.

In terms of the characters, I found Winnie sweet and I very much liked her, but I actually ended up entirely disliking Kilraven, finding him to be a cold and selfish person. Putting aside the implausible reason as to why they had to get married. The very reason he thought it would be acceptable is pretty ghastly. Then let’s look at the sex scene itself. Kilraven ends up hurting Winnie so much during their consummation that she cries all the way through it. But this is ok because he hasn’t had sex for seven years and couldn’t help himself and you know, he made up for it afterwards! Ugh, at this point I did actually shout at my iPod.

The narrator to the audiobook was male. I’m not sure how I feel about male narrators to romance books, or whether I just did not engage with this narrator. But he certainly didn’t help with my overall problems with the book. The falsetto voice he used for the female characters was very odd.

VERDICT


I do hate giving negative reviews to books as I am conscious that this is someone’s livelihood. But I’m afraid my advice here would be to save your money.

You can find out more about this author here:

Carolyn

A zombie loving Brit chick who has a series addiction to books, chocolate and shopping - is also partial to a sexy archangel, or two… favourite genres are urban fantasy, horror and paranormal romance. Also loves horror flicks as well as books, especially of the zombie variety… Brrraaaaiiinnnnsss!

3 Comments


Book Chick City June 26, 2011 at 11:39 am

So unlike you to give such a negative review – 1/10!! You really must of hated it – sounds pretty bad, especially the so called"love-making" scene, sounded more like rape! Thanks for the review, but I'll definitely steer clear of this one :)

Reply

Nikki-ann June 26, 2011 at 2:18 pm

One to steer clear of then!

Reply

Laura Summers (BCC) June 26, 2011 at 9:45 pm

@bookchickcity I know :-( I so hate giving negative reviews too. But this book unfortunately did not work for me on any level. The "love-making" scene, wasn't rape as it was consentual, but the whole scene just left me with a sour taste in my mouth.

@Niiki-Ann unfortunately I would say so :-(

Reply

Leave a Comment


 

 

 

About Us

Welcome to Book Chick City! We review horror, urban fantasy and paranormal romance, basically anything with a supernatural element. We share our thoughts in an honest, conversational way. As well as book reviews you will find author interviews, recommendations, giveaways and film reviews. To find out more about us go to our About page.

If you wish to have a book reviewed, please read Book Chick City's REVIEW POLICY before sending your request. Thank you.

UK Publisher Month

Throughout May we will be celebrating UK publishers and their books. Editors and publicists will be revealing some of their upcoming titles for 2012 and giving us a glimpse into their working lives. There will also be lots of giveaways!

Win 7 Fabulous Books!
Win 3 Books from Berkley!
Angry Robot Giveaway!

BCC Recommends

• Check out Book Chick City's Recommended Reads for April 2012

• Check out Book Chick City's Recommended Reads for March 2012

BCC on Facebook!

Site Sponsors

BCC’s Reading Challenges

Copyright

All content and illustrations Ⓒ Book Chick City unless otherwise stated. This means you shouldn't copy or distribute without our permission!

Archives

Search the Blog