[color-box]The Geek Girl and the Scandalous Earl by Gina Lamm (Geek Girls #1)
Sourcebooks Casablanca (5 March 2013) Paperback / Ebook: 352 pages
Historical / Paranormal Romance
Website  Series Listing  Amazon UK / US

Rating: 2halfstars[/color-box]

The Geek Girl and the Scandalous Earl

Jamie Marten is a modern gamer girl thrown into the past by a magic portal. Stuck in a time where communication is more face-to-face than FaceTime, Jamie must learn how to fit in if she ever wants to get home. However, as she gets to know Micah Axelby, her gracious host, going home may be the last thing on her mind.

I can’t tell you how much I wanted to read this book – it sounded like exactly the type of thing I enjoy. The nerdy, slightly socially inept girl goes back to a time where social niceties are the be-all and end-all, and meets her very own Mr Darcy type character. There was so much opportunity in this novel, but despite enjoying it, I just don’t think Gina Lamm took advantage of them all.

It was a very promising start – after a little bit of an introduction into Jamie’s life, we jump pretty much straight into the action. She grabs the handle of a bureau while sorting out a storage unit in order to make some money, and pooof – there she is in 1816. Lamm quickly got some laughs in, as Micah immediately assumes that Jamie is a courtesan come to tempt him and takes it completely in his stride, as though it happens to him all the time.  I think there more scope for humour in this book, with all the misunderstandings that are bound to come from being 200 years apart. Apart from some rather unladylike swearing on Jamie’s behalf – one instance of which I did particularly enjoy –

“That’s me.” Jamie said glumly (…) “Luckiest bitch alive”

humour just wasn’t utilised like it could have been.

As a character, Jamie manages to carry her modernity awkwardly around with her in 1816 with very little being said about the matter. On her few meetings with Micah’s acquaintances first names are used without regards for the social niceties. I can see why Jamie would act this way, as a modern character, and I feel that it could have been a plot point but it was just let go, by and large. Other than that, there is not a lot of characterisation going on – Jamie still refers sporadically to her love for technology, and recreates a computer set up for Micah to experience, but she doesn’t seem to miss it as much as she might considering her previous dependence on it – although considering she was recovering from break up at the beginning of the novel, this might well have given her the impetus she needed to get out and away from the computer. In a way, Micah’s characterisation is just as scanty – he thinks of himself as a noble gentleman, and that’s supposedly what spurs his actions, although he doesn’t act very nobly at points throughout the novel. Other than that we know very little about him, except that there is some scandal surrounding him due to an ex-lover’s death.

In fact, there isn’t a lot to say about Jamie and Micah’s interaction altogether – they barely tolerate each other at first, and then suddenly Jamie is entertaining the notion that she might love him, egged on by Mrs Knightsbridge – housekeeper, caretaker, woman of mystery. Jamie then begins making the effort to spend more time with Micah and a relationship does evolve, although where the initial spark comes from isn’t really apparent – the two have (obviously) very little in common. She ‘takes’ Micah out on a modern date including pizza, which I thought was a really nice idea and foreshadows the ending of the novel, but I think there could definitely have been a fuller picture painted of life in 1816.

The plot itself is a little hard to stomach – even for a novel about time travel. The mysterious Mrs Knightsbridge has a hand in the occurrences, as we find out relatively early on in the story, but this never really comes to fruition – partly because the ending is a little rushed. Even the allusions to her involvement throughout the story are quite vague and arbitrary. The author has obviously realised that there needs to be some sort of explanation for Jamie whizzing back in time, but I don’t think it was developed quite far enough and it fell by the wayside at times despite it being a pretty large part of the story. There is a ‘suspense’ storyline which finds Jamie in danger from an ‘unkown’ source and sees our heroine being fairly TSTL. However, although this does drive the romance plot along towards its conclusion, there isn’t much of a mystery and one of Micah’s less noble moments happens as a result.


All in all, The Geek Girl and the Scandalous Earl was an enjoyable book, but it definitely had its flaws. Any disappointment was partially my own fault as I had such high expectations. As a fun and entertaining light read it ticks all the right boxes, but I expected a little more substance with regards to the cultural differences of Jamie and Micah.


I am a recent University graduate with a BA in English and an undiminished love of reading. I will give pretty much anything a go – although I do have a fondness for both paranormal and historical romance, urban fantasy and historical biographies. I always have my head in a book, and I have a problem – I can’t stop buying books! [Bobby no longer reviews for BCC]


Carolyn August 15, 2013 at 8:46 am

Awww that’s a shame you didn’t care for this one much. It looked like such a cute read.


Bobby Boxall August 15, 2013 at 8:41 pm

I really wish I could have liked it more, because it wasn’t badly written or boring – I just think it didn’t reach its potential :(


Kearstie August 15, 2013 at 3:11 pm

That sucks that this fell flat… it did look cute!

A note on the not-so-brilliant cover art… sticking dark framed glasses on a model does not a “geek” make. Not that a model could not be a geek… with or without the glasses, she could be a total geek-at-heart. However, the thick, dark glasses plopped on her face to signify geekiness is both stereotypical and poorly rendered.

As a point of interest, Bobby, is she at least described like on the cover in the books?

Ugh… why have I been having so many issues with cover art lately?

Regardless… great review!


Bobby Boxall August 15, 2013 at 8:37 pm

It wish I could have liked it more, because it did sound really fun and it delivered in some ways.

I know exactly what you mean about the glasses thing! There are many ways they could have signified her ‘geek’ status – some of which would also have emphasised the time travel aspect of the novel.

I will be completely honest with you Kearstie – descriptions of characters appearances are one of the things I tend to gloss over in a novel. I don’t know why, but if asked to describe a character I almost always have to go back and reread – unless it’s a character from Harry Potter or something like that. However, I do remember a few mentions of her streaked hair. I don’t recall any mention of glasses but I can’t be certain that I haven’t just missed it.

Thank you :)


Kearstie August 15, 2013 at 8:48 pm

Yes the cover does not seem to do the story justice at all… no tech stuff, no time travel references… It says basically nothing about the book. Plus, what you see of his pants looks kind of modern, as well as his hairstyle. Sigh.

I always find it interesting what people gloss over versus what they’re look for. With me, I’m looking for that description. I want it vague, but I need it to be there. A simple hair color, eye color, stature and body type, and I can picture my hero or heroine clearly, which makes me happy. But I know many people, like you, who could not care less about that stuff. Funny how the mind works!

I SEE NO HAIR STREAKS!!! Gah! lol :)


Laura August 16, 2013 at 8:38 am

Huh I’m gutted this didn’t leave up to expectations as I normally love time travels romances and this one looks so fun. Harumph. Don’t you just hate it when that happens? :(


Leave a Comment





NEW VIDEO *spoilers*



Carolyn (Editor)
YouTuber. Animal Lover. Coffee Addict. Zombie Fan. Reader of all the books.

Laura (Reviewer)
Bookworm. Handbag addict. Mother. Lover of lovely things.

Rebecca (Reviewer)
English graduate. Avid reader. Movie Fan.

Louise (Reviewer)
Romance Junkie. TV Addict. Lover of All Things Robert Downey JNR.




Our REVIEW will be up soon, in the meantime, check it out on GOODREADS


Currently Reading









Top 10 2015



All content and illustrations Ⓒ Book Chick City unless otherwise stated. This means you shouldn't copy or distribute without our permission!